Рассмотрим моделирование бизнеса с точки зрения представителей второй группы людей – исполнителей. Задачей этих исполнителей является выполнение неких действий, согласованное как внутри процесса, так и с другими процессами предприятия. В большинстве случаев, во вторую группу входят наемные работники, но могут быть ситуации, когда представитель первой группы включен в процесс как равноправный участник. Так что границы между группами весьма условны.
Модель бизнес-процесса предназначена для описания действий при производстве продукта процесса. Действия могут выполнять люди, оборудование, программные системы и т.д. Люди, участвующие в бизнес-процессе могут выступать в различных ролях:
- владелец процесса,
- владелец ресурса,
- член команды процесса,
- клиент процесса и т.д.
Очевидно, что интересы людей, выступающих в различных ролях, могут не совпадать, а порой и противоречить друг другу.
Поэтому для одного и того же бизнес-процесса по созданию какого-либо продукта может быть построено несколько различных моделей, отражающих различные ролевые точки зрения. Как когда-то сказал предтеча бизнес-анализа Рудольф Акофф: «Намерения дающего редко совпадают с намерениями берущего».
Будем считать, что если в моделях бизнес-процесса, построенных для каждой точки зрения, достигнуто согласие по включенным в них ролям, то согласие между всеми ролями достигнуто по бизнес-процессу в целом.
Какие точки зрения должны быть рассмотрены при моделировании конкретного бизнес-процесса – должно быть четко оговорено в задании, которое получает бизнес-аналитик от своего заказчика. По умолчанию, я бы рекомендовал строить модель бизнес-процесса с точки зрения владельца бизнес-процесса. Если моделирование бизнес-процессов выполняется с целью внедрения информационных технологий, целесообразно дополнительно рассмотреть точку зрения члена команды бизнес-процесса.
Чем больше точек зрения смоделировано, тем более адекватным становится описание бизнес-процесса и тем легче может пройти последующая его автоматизация или сертификация системы менеджмента качества.
Если возникает вопрос, в каком порядке моделировать точки зрения бизнес-процессов, однозначной рекомендации у меня нет. Как правило, я начинаю моделирование с той точки зрения, которая либо наиболее востребована, либо вызывает наибольшее сопротивление у персонала. В первом случае это походит на прорыв в крепость на плечах ее защитников, во втором – на уничтожение наиболее укрепленного узла обороны, сломив который все остальные можно брать без сопротивления…
Откуда и почему берется сопротивление – разговор длинный, но как-нибудь я обязательно расскажу и об этом.
Наверх
|
Комментарии
best online international pharmacies canadian pharmacy online
london drugs canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
publix pharmacy online ordering medicine online shopping
shoppers drug mart canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian pharmacies canada pharmaceutical online ordering
pharmacy online shopping https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian drugs pharmacies online pharmacies online
online pharmacies in usa https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian drugstore pharmacy online no prescription
pharmacy discount https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian pharmacy king walmart pharmacy online
canadian drugs pharmacies online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
online pharmacies of canada canadian pharcharmy online
pharmacy in canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada drugs pharmacy canadian online pharmacies
shoppers drug mart canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
http://jmgarage.ru/wiki/index.php/User:Jeremy9406
pharmacy in canada canada pharmaceuticals online
mexican border pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
online pharmacies canada canada pharmaceuticals online
canada pharmacy online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian pharmacy cialis 20mg canadian pharmacies-24h
online pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
best online canadian pharmacy canadian drugs
approved canadian online pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
discount pharmacies online canadian pharcharmy
canadian prescriptions online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
https://mokujipedia.net/view/%E5%88%A9%E7%94%A8%E8%80%85:BrentonCopeley
canadian viagra generic pharmacy prescription drugs from canada
navarro pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
aarp recommended canadian pharmacies canadian pharmacies online
pharmacies in canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
online pharmacies canada navarro pharmacy miami
cialis generic pharmacy online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian drugs pharmacy pharmacy online no prescription
medical pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada pharmaceuticals online generic canada pharmaceuticals online
pharmacy intern https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian pharmacies-247 walmart pharmacy online
cheap prescription drugs https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
http://18.224.43.11/wiki/User:ShoshanaHuonDeKe
canada discount drug canada pharmaceuticals online
canadian viagra https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
international pharmacy canadian prescriptions online
online canadian pharcharmy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
drugstore online shopping online pharmacies
canadian pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
https://wiki.epicmafia.org/index.php?title=User:RexUvw66372
http://refugee.wiki/tiki-index.php?page=UserPagealanaxbottpwresbq
canadian pharmacy generic viagra online medicine tablets shopping
online pharmacies uk https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
cheap prescription drugs canadian drugstore
approved canadian online pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
best canadian online pharmacies pharmacy uk
national pharmacies online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
http://jmgarage.ru/wiki/index.php/User:YvetteBronson
canadian pharmacy cialis 20mg online drugstore pharmacy
shoppers pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
https://example.tanundacricketclub.org.au/pages/ViolakeTebbuttan
national pharmacies online canada pharmaceuticals online
cialis pharmacy online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy online no prescription canadian pharmaceuticals online
canadian pharmacies-24h https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
online drugstore pharmacy pharmacy online shopping
canada pharmaceutical online ordering https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
medical pharmacies canada pharmacy
drugstore online shopping https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
london drugs canada canadian pharmacies online
pharmacy on line https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
shoppers pharmacy canadian pharmacy
canadian pharmacy king https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
best online canadian pharmacy national pharmacies online
online pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada drugs pharmacy online online canadian pharcharmy
shoppers pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
discount pharmacy canadian pharmaceuticals
approved canadian online pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
shoppers drug mart canada pharmacy
canadian pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
cheap prescription drugs online medicine tablets shopping
walmart pharmacy viagra https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian online pharmacy international pharmacy
publix pharmacy online ordering https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada drugs online pharmacy online
canadian drugs pharmacies online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
indian pharmacy online medicine order discount
shoppers pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
best online international pharmacies shoppers drug mart pharmacy
viagra generic online pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada pharmacy online canadian pharmaceuticals online safe
walmart pharmacy online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacies online online pharmacy drugstore
canada pharmaceuticals online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
mexican pharmacies pharmacy online
online pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada pharmacy online pharmacy uk
canadian pharmaceuticals online safe https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian online pharmacy canadian drugs online pharmacy
online canadian pharcharmy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
panacea pharmacy canadian pharmacy cialis 20mg
cheap prescription drugs https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada pharmaceuticals online generic canada pharmaceutical online ordering
pharmacy online no prescription https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian drugs online pharmacies canada discount drug
viagra pharmacy 100mg https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
aarp recommended canadian pharmacies online medicine shopping
canada drugs online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian prescriptions online canadian online pharmacy
indian pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
aarp recommended canadian pharmacies pharmacy online
canada pharmaceuticals online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
viagra pharmacy 100mg buy viagra pharmacy 100mg
canada pharmaceuticals online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
cheap prescription drugs canadian pharmacies
canadian pharmacy generic viagra https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
online pharmacies legitimate pharmeasy
canada drugs online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
viagra generic canadian pharmacy canadian pharcharmy
buy generic viagra online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
walmart pharmacy online cialis pharmacy online
canada pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
24 hour pharmacy order medicine online
indian pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy online prescription navarro pharmacy
online pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada pharmacy canadian drugs pharmacies online
indian pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
discount pharmacies medicine online shopping
canada pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
online pharmacies uk cheap prescription drugs
pharmacy discount https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
shoppers drug mart pharmacy pharmacies in canada
canadian pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian drugs online pharmacies online order medicine
canadian pharmaceuticals https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada pharmacy canadian online pharmacy
canada pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
national pharmacies online online medicine order discount
online pharmacies in usa https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
online drugstore pharmacy cheap prescription drugs
canadian pharmaceuticals online safe https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
walgreens pharmacy online online pharmacy canada
canadian pharmaceuticals online safe https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
prescription drugs from canada indian pharmacy
shoppers drug mart pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
best canadian online pharmacies pharmacies
shoppers drug mart canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy online shopping online medicine to buy
canadian drugs online pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada discount drug 24 hour pharmacy
pharmacy online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
online drugstore canadian online pharmacies
canadian drugs pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pills viagra pharmacy 100mg canadian pharmacies
best online canadian pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian viagra generic pharmacy canadian pharmacy review
online pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
viagra generic online pharmacy pharmacies
viagra pharmacy 100mg https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada pharmaceuticals online generic compound pharmacy
discount pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacies shipping to usa canadian pharmacies online
canadian pharmacies online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada discount drug online order medicine
drugstore online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
international pharmacy pharmacy online
pharmacies online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
navarro pharmacy walmart pharmacy online
pharmacies in canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
panacea pharmacy canadian pharmaceuticals online
canada drugs pharmacy online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
discount pharmacy pharmacies online
pharmacies online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
london drugs canada pharmacy online no prescription
canada pharmaceuticals online generic https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian pharmacy review international pharmacy
canadian pharmacy drugs online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
london drugs canada canadian drugstore
canadian pharmacy viagra generic https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian viagra 24 hour pharmacy
national pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada pharmaceutical online ordering medicine online shopping
national pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
cheap pharmacy online pharmacies
online pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
london drugs canada walmart pharmacy viagra
shoppers drug mart pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
shoppers pharmacy canadian drugs online pharmacy
online pharmacies of canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
publix pharmacy online ordering pharmacy online
shoppers drug mart pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy online canadian pharmaceuticals online
online pharmacies in usa https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian drugs pharmacy online pharmacy
canadian online pharmacies legitimate https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian pharmacy viagra generic canada drugs online
canadian pharmaceuticals https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian pharmaceuticals online shoppers drug mart pharmacy
canadian pharmacy king https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian drugs pharmacies online canadia online pharmacy
pharmacies online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
viagra generic canadian pharmacy pharmeasy
canadian pharmaceuticals https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
international pharmacy pharmacy online
online canadian pharcharmy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy cheap no prescription online order medicine
canadian viagra generic pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
online pharmacy drugstore canadian pharmacy
pharmacies shipping to usa https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy cheap no prescription canada drugs online
drugstore online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian drugs pharmacies online best canadian online pharmacies
canada pharmaceuticals https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
24 hour pharmacy online pharmacies of canada
viagra generic canadian pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy online no prescription online pharmacies
canadian viagra generic pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada discount drug canadian online pharmacies
pharmacies online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy online prescription medicine online order
pills viagra pharmacy 100mg https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacies shipping to usa online medicine to buy
discount pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
buy generic viagra online walgreens pharmacy online
apollo pharmacy online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
online pharmacies canada canadian pharmaceuticals online
london drugs canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacies shipping to usa pharmacies shipping to usa
canadian online pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian pharmacies international pharmacy
pharmacy drugstore online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada discount drug online pharmacy busted
online pharmacy busted https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
aarp recommended canadian pharmacies discount pharmacies
walgreens pharmacy online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy online online pharmacies legitimate
viagra generic canadian pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
prescription drugs from canada canadian online pharmacies legitimate
canada pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy discount pharmacy in canada
generic viagra online pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy discount canadian viagra generic pharmacy
pharmacy drugstore online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
walmart pharmacy online medicine online shopping
drugstore online shopping https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian drugstore canadian pharmacy king
online pharmacies canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
online pharmacy busted navarro pharmacy miami
canadia online pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
24 hour pharmacy pharmacy on line
walmart pharmacy viagra https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada pharmacy online pharmacy online
canadian viagra https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian viagra generic pharmacy canadian online pharmacies
canadian prescriptions online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
navarro pharmacy generic viagra online pharmacy
panacea pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadia online pharmacy order medicine online
canadian viagra https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy in canada canadian drugstore
pharmacies shipping to usa https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
national pharmacies canadian online pharmacies
canadian pharmacy online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
discount pharmacies online pharmacies
canadian pharmacies-247 https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy in canada canadian pharmaceuticals online
canadian cialis https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacies in canada generic viagra online pharmacy
shoppers drug mart canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
apollo pharmacy online canadian drugs pharmacies online
national pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
online pharmacies legitimate pharmacies online
pharmacy discount https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
best online canadian pharmacy canada pharmacies
canada drugs online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
medical pharmacies canadian online pharmacies legitimate
walmart pharmacy viagra https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
approved canadian online pharmacies pharmacies
pharmacy cheap no prescription https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada pharmaceutical online ordering canada pharmacies
canadian viagra https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
walmart pharmacy viagra shoppers drug mart canada
canadian pharmacies-247 https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
on line pharmacy canadian pharmacies online
online drugstore pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
walgreens pharmacy online online medicine shopping
walmart pharmacy viagra https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian online pharmacy canadian pharmacies
canadian pharmacy king https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
shoppers drug mart canada international pharmacy
apollo pharmacy online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian drugs pharmacy pharmacy uk
online drugstore https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian pharmacy online best canadian online pharmacy
canadian pharmaceuticals online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy discount drugstore online
canada pharmaceuticals online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada pharmacy cheap pharmacy online
canada discount drug https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
generic viagra online pharmeasy
pharmacy online drugstore https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy online pharmacy in canada
canadian pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian pharmacies-247 pharmeasy
canadian government approved pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
walgreens pharmacy online best canadian online pharmacy
pharmacy intern https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy online no prescription canadian pharmaceuticals online
approved canadian online pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pills viagra pharmacy 100mg navarro pharmacy
drugstore online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian online pharmacies legitimate drugstore online
online pharmacies of canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
indian pharmacy canadian drugs
shoppers pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
drugstore online pharmacy online drugstore
online pharmacies of canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian pharmaceuticals online safe pharmacy intern
canadian pharmacies-24h https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
publix pharmacy online ordering pharmacy
buy generic viagra online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
online pharmacies uk canadian drugs pharmacies online
pharmacy online drugstore https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy online shopping online order medicine
cialis generic pharmacy online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian pharmacy drugs online medicine online shopping
canada drugs online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
buy generic viagra online best online canadian pharmacy
pharmacy online drugstore https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian online pharmacies compound pharmacy
online canadian pharcharmy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
cialis generic pharmacy online online medicine to buy
shoppers drug mart canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
mexican pharmacies canadian pharmacy
pharmacies online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacy discount online pharmacies canada
pharmacy drugstore online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian drugs pharmacies online canadian pharcharmy
compound pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
cialis pharmacy online medical pharmacies
publix pharmacy online ordering https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian pharmaceuticals canadian pharmaceuticals online safe
pharmacy online drugstore https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
mexican pharmacies international pharmacy
shoppers drug mart canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian government approved pharmacies canada pharmacy
canadian pharmacy king https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
cheap pharmacy online pharmacy uk
canadian pharmacy king https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian cialis best online canadian pharmacy
canadian pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
international pharmacy canadian pharmacies-24h
canadian pharcharmy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
generic viagra online 24 hour pharmacy
compound pharmacy https://buyviagraonliney.com/
pharmacy online cheap online canadian pharcharmy
panacea pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
medical pharmacy national pharmacies
canadian pharmacy king https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
walmart pharmacy online canada pharmaceuticals online
canadian pharmacy online viagra https://buyviagraonliney.com/
online pharmacies uk online pharmacy
pharmacy online cheap https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
indian pharmacy panacea pharmacy
canadian drugs pharmacy https://buyviagraonliney.com/
generic viagra online online medicine tablets shopping
pills viagra pharmacy 100mg https://buyviagraonliney.com/
cheap pharmacy online best online international pharmacies
online pharmacy canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
cialis pharmacy online canada pharmaceutical online ordering
24 hour pharmacy https://buyviagraonliney.com/
national pharmacies online international pharmacy
canadian pharmacy viagra generic https://buyviagraonliney.com/
canadian online pharmacies legitimate online pharmacies of canada
cialis pharmacy online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian viagra medicine online shopping
pills viagra pharmacy 100mg https://buyviagraonliney.com/
walgreens pharmacy online canada pharmacies
shoppers drug mart pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
panacea pharmacy london drugs canada
canada pharmaceutical online ordering https://buyviagraonliney.com/
online pharmacies uk online medicine tablets shopping
canadian pharcharmy online https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
prescription drugs from canada discount pharmacy
drugstore online https://buyviagraonliney.com/
online canadian pharcharmy medicine online order
canadian viagra generic pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian drugs online pharmacies canada pharmacy online
online pharmacies uk https://buyviagraonliney.com/
canadian pharmacies-24h drugstore online
shoppers drug mart canada https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
discount pharmacy canada pharmaceuticals online
online pharmacies legitimate https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacies shipping to usa pharmacies shipping to usa
walgreens pharmacy online https://buyviagraonliney.com/
canadian pharmaceuticals online canada pharmacies
canadian online pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
cialis pharmacy online mexican border pharmacies
cheap pharmacy online https://buyviagraonliney.com/
viagra generic canadian pharmacy online order medicine
canadian pharmacy generic viagra https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
online pharmacy canada canadian pharmacies online
canadian pharmacies-24h https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian pharmacies-24h canadian drugs
national pharmacies online https://buyviagraonliney.com/
indian pharmacy shoppers drug mart pharmacy
mexican border pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
drugstore online pharmacy online
canadian pharcharmy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canada online pharmacies online pharmacies legitimate
canadian pharmacy online viagra https://buyviagraonliney.com/
canadian pharmacies-247 canada drugs pharmacy
discount pharmacies https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
canadian pharmacy international pharmacy
buy viagra pharmacy 100mg https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
discount canadian drugs navarro pharmacy
canadian drugs pharmacy https://buyviagraonliney.com/
publix pharmacy online ordering canadian pharmacy online
walmart pharmacy viagra https://buyviagraonlinet.com/
pharmacies online canadian online pharmacies
compound pharmacy https://buyviagraonlinet.com/